Extra Income Report: How We Made $24,159 in May

how to make extra income monthly report

how to make extra income monthly report

Welcome to the Wealthy Nickel Extra Income Report! Each month, I share all the different ways we make extra income outside the 9-5 job.

For a little background, I decided to share my side hustle income for a few reasons:

  1. To show you exactly how I make extra money while working a full time job
  2. To keep me accountable to my goals, and
  3. To inspire you to start your own money-making ventures on the side.

My family lives on a single income, and we are blessed that that income is enough to pay the bills and put food on the table. But we decided several years ago that we wanted to pursue financial independence and be able to “retire” (whatever that means) long before we hit 65.

In order to do that, we needed to supercharge our savings, which was not going to happen on a single income. We needed to figure out how to make additional income. And with 2 young kids we needed something that didn’t require a huge time commitment. Hence our first side hustle (real estate rentals) was born.

Since then, we’ve tried lots of different side hustles. As we experiment with new ideas, I will share our strategies here. None of this is rocket science, but my hope is you will be able to learn from our extra income projects and apply what you learn to your own projects.

There are a million different ways you can earn extra income on the side, and I certainly haven’t tried everything. There are a lot of good ideas out there that may be a better fit for you. If you want to get some more ideas, I have a Side Hustle Interview Series that documents creative ways others are making money on the side.

With that out of the way, let’s get to this month’s income report!



While we made over $100k in 2018 from side hustles and passive income, I don’t think that’s a realistic goal for 2019. Almost half of that income came from a flip and wholesale deal we did, and we made the decision to ramp down our flipping business while we have very young kids.

Since we’ve been making moves with our real estate portfolio to make it more passive, I do believe our real estate crowdfunding cash flow should increase this year to make up for some of our lost active income.

  • Cash Back Apps: $500
    • I started looking for the best cash back apps in September of last year, and think between my wife and I we can make $500 per year with minimal effort.
  • Credit Card Rewards: $1,000
    • It’s time to sign up for another couple of rewards credit cards this year. If we can get 2 cards with a $500 bonus each, we’ll knock this one out easily.
  • Interest Earned: $1,000
    • Since selling off some of our real estate, we’ve slowly been moving money into crowdfunding or other investments. But we have a decent amount of cash laying around. I’m currently earning 2.2% at Ally Bank right now, but need to switch over to CIT Bank as they are paying 2.4%!
  • Realtor Commissions: $15,000
    • My wife has been able to make $15-20k the last few years just from random friends and family transactions. There’s no business in the pipeline, and we don’t do any marketing, but something usually pans out throughout the year.
  • Real Estate Crowdfunding: $25,000
    • We have a significant chunk of money in real estate crowdfunding and other private equity deals. Some send us a monthly or quarterly check, while others won’t pay us a dime for 5 years or more. Based on the types of deals we’re in, I think we should be able to get $25k in passive cash flow delivered to our mailbox in 2019 🙂
  • Rental Properties: $25,000
    • We don’t have any big plans to buy or sell any rental properties this year. My goal is to make $300 cash flow per month for each of our 7 units, which comes out to just over $25k.
  • Blogging: $500
    • Right now blogging is a fun hobby that has cost me a few hundred dollars so far. I’m hoping in 2019 I’ll be able to turn a small profit. We’ll see!
  • Total Extra Income Goal: $68,000

Most of our extra income relies on real estate, which is very lumpy. But on average, our goal is to make $5,667 per month.


  • Cash Back Apps
    • This Month: $84
    • Year to Date: $290
  • Credit Card Rewards
    • This Month: $0
    • Year to Date: $1,000
  • Interest Earned
    • This Month: $109
    • Year to Date: $938
  • Realtor Commissions
    • This Month: $0
    • Year to Date: $10,191
  • Real Estate Crowdfunding
    • This Month: $899
    • Year to Date: $9,323
  • Real Estate Flips
    • This Month: $30,000
    • Year to Date: $30,000
  • Rental Properties
    • This Month: -$7,082
    • Year to Date: -$2,060
  • Blogging
    • This Month: $149
    • Year to Date: $435
  • Total Extra Income: $24,159

In total, we made $24,159 this month. This was in large part due to the sale of our flip property much earlier than anticipated!

Our side hustle income is generally very lumpy and depends heavily on when my wife pulls in a real estate commission check, or if we have a big repair bill on a rental property. Since we closed on our flip property (income we weren’t expecting to have this year), we decided to do some capital improvements on our rentals which will end up costing around $20,000 and most likely leave us cash flow negative on our rental properties for the year. We’ve enjoyed several good years of above pro forma returns on our rental properties, and apparently this is the year to even things out.

RELATED: How We Got Started on our Side Hustle Journey


With the closing of our flip property, we are now way ahead of our goal for the year with $50,117 in extra income so far.

But as mentioned above, we are in the midst of some capital improvements at one of our rental properties, so expect that number to actually come down in the next 1-2 months.

Extra Income Report progress chart


A couple months ago we closed on a house we’d had under contract for 2 years (!!!) 

After reviewing contractor bids, our partners and us decided to see if we could sell it off-market to another investor at a price we liked and avoid the renovation, sale, and all the risk that entails. We ended up getting it under contract as-is, and it closed in May.

While I’m sad that we won’t get to renovate it and make an ugly house pretty again, it makes a lot of sense from a numbers standpoint. We bought the house for $80,000 and thought it was worth somewhere around $275,000 once it was fixed up. We got multiple bids to do the work that ranged from $90 – $120,000.

Once you figured in holding costs, selling costs, and rehab, we each stood to make around $33-35,000 in profit after it was all said and done. Those are great numbers, but we were actually able to sell the property as-is for $150,000. So we each walked away with about $30,000 in profit (we made $30k, they made slightly less due to our partnership structure) without having to take on the risk of the rehab or continue holding the property for 3-4 months during construction. I don’t know about you, but I’ll gladly trade $3-5k in profit for those benefits!

The buyer is a custom home builder we found through a Facebook group, and so he can probably get the rehab done for less than us because he has his own construction crew. I look forward to seeing the finished product when it hits the market, and am happy we got to be a small part of the process of improving this neighborhood.

picture of side hustle house flip
Isn’t she a beauty?


I have a goal to make an extra $500 per year from cash back apps. $500 per year breaks down to about $42 per month, so with our total income of $290 we are on pace to beat our goal for the year.

If there is one app I’d recommend to anyone in the personal finance space, it’s Drop. I’ve found that Drop consistently has finance-related offers that pay you $10-50 just to sign up and participate in a free app of some kind.

A couple months ago, I got $15 for joining Twine – a savings app for couples. And this month I set up a free account with SoFi Wealth and deposited $100. Per the terms, as long as I leave the account open for 90 days I’ll make $50, which is a 200% annualized return on my money!

The beauty of cash back apps is that they require almost zero work. It’s basically free money if you do any shopping with credit cards, and the cash back stacks on top of your credit card rewards. In this day and age, between credit card rewards and cash back apps, you should be able to make at least 3-5% back on every purchase you make.

I have downloaded dozens of cash back apps in search of the ones that pay out the most money for the least amount of work. Once I determine which ones work best, I get my wife to sign up (using my referral code of course for an extra $5-10 bonus). Since my wife does most of the day to day shopping and online purchases for our family, she’s really the one making most of the money.

RELATED: The Only 2 Sites You Need to Make $100 A Month Taking Online Surveys

As of April 2019, here are the apps on my phone:

1. Drop

Drop is one of my favorite apps because it doesn’t require me to do anything at all. I just downloaded the app and linked my credit card. Now when I make purchases on my credit card, it automatically adds points to my account.

If you want to try it out you can sign up here and get a $5 bonus when you link your credit card (that is an affiliate link – I get a small commission if you join that helps keep the lights on around here).

8582 504662 - Extra Income Report: How We Made $24,159 in May8582 - Extra Income Report: How We Made $24,159 in May

2. Dosh

Dosh is very similar to Drop – once you link a credit card you don’t have to do anything else but collect your cash. Where Drop let’s you earn cash back at a set of specific stores that you choose, Dosh gives you cash back at wider range of stores. I’ve noticed that Dosh tends to have a lot of local restaurants in its list (usually with 5% cash back).

You can sign up to try Dosh through this link and get a $5 bonus (again, that’s my affiliate link).

3. Ebates

Where Drop and Dosh give you cash back for local shopping, Ebates is all about online shopping. If you’re like my family, we buy everything we can online, and Ebates helps us save 2-5% on almost every purchase.

Ebates is probably the most well-known app on my list, and for good reason. It has relationships with a huge number of retailers, so you can get cash back for almost anything you buy online.

Ebates is currently giving out a $10 bonus when you spend $25 if you sign up through this link. (That’s my referral link. I get a small bonus in my Ebates account when you get a bonus.)

4. Ibotta

I am on the fence with Ibotta. I think it’s a great app to save money on groceries, and lots of people who use it rave about it. You can get cash back at almost every grocery store imaginable by selecting offers in the app on various products you buy on a weekly basis.

Unfortunately, we do most of our grocery shopping at Aldi’s, which is pretty much the ONLY grocery store not affiliated with Ibotta. (But don’t feel too bad for me, Aldi’s is the best thing that’s ever happened to our grocery budget). We still do a little shopping at “normal” grocery stores, so it’s worth keeping on my phone for now.

I do heartily recommend the app to anyone who shops at a grocery store other than Aldi’s. Ibotta advertises that their average user saves $20 per month ($240 per year) for a few minutes of work each week.

If you want to give it a try, you can get a $10 bonus when you start shopping with Ibotta here. (Like Ebates, I get a small bonus in my Ibotta account when you get your bonus.)

5. Pei (NEW – get a $15 bonus with referral code s2jv9p)

I just started using a new app called Pei, which is similar to Dosh and Drop. You just link a credit card and start earning cash back (on top of your regular credit card rewards) when you use that card at participating stores. It also seems to stack on top of Dosh and Drop, so you can earn double or triple cash back at the same store if you use multiple apps!

I’ve only been using the app for about a week, but I’ve gotten cash back at Starbucks, Chipotle, Target, 7-Eleven, and Papa Murphy’s. They have a pretty impressive list of stores where you can earn cash back, unlike some other apps.

As of this writing, you can get a $15 bonus with Pei if you sign up using this link and use the referral code s2jv9p (you must type in the referral code to get the bonus, it won’t automatically populate).



Last year, I decided to report the income when we actually cashed out the reward points. I am rethinking that, and may report the income when we receive the rewards. Most of our rewards are Chase Ultimate Rewards Points, which we can generally get a redemption rate of 1.5:1 on when we book travel, but I would just value them at a purely cash value of 100 points to $1.

Nothing to report for credit card rewards in May. We have a pretty good sized bank of Chase points stored up for future travel. We are planning a trip this summer, and trying to decide whether to fly or drive. If we fly, tickets are almost $500 each for a relatively short domestic flight, which is crazy to me. I am looking into applying for a Chase Ink business card for my wife to get an 80,000 point bonus after spending $5,000 in the first 3 months (I’ve already gotten one for myself last year).

We add about 3-4,000 points ($30-40) a month just from our normal credit card use, mainly on our Chase cards. We’ve got a balance of about 120,000 points right now, which at our average redemption rate of 1.5:1 is worth $1,800 toward travel costs. We try to open a couple new cards per year to get the sign-up bonuses. I don’t have the next one planned, so I need to get on that!

I absolutely love credit card rewards, as we haven’t paid for a plane ticket in almost 3 years now. I need to write a post about our strategy, but you can find lots of info online just by googling “travel reward hacking”.

How to Get Started With Credit Card Rewards (And Earn $600)

For the newbie, I recommend the Chase Sapphire card as your starting point. I signed up for one in my name, and another in my wife’s name over the last year to get a 50,000 point sign-up bonus for each of us (100,000 points total = about $1500 toward travel in our scenario above!)

You have to spend $4,000 on the card in order to get the bonus, so if you want to try the same thing make sure you space it out so you can hit the spending requirement. There is also a $95 annual fee. When I reach the anniversary on my card, I plan to call Chase and get it downgraded to a no annual fee card.

NOTE: This offer has since expired, and the current offer is even better. You can now get 100,000 bonus points after spending $4,000 in the first 3 months!

Check out the Chase Sapphire card here and see if you qualify for the 100,000 point sign-up bonus.


We have a decent amount of cash sitting around in emergency funds and reserve funds for our rental properties, as well as money waiting to be invested in passive crowdfunding projects.

This month we earned $140. Most of our money is in an Ally Bank account earning 2.2%, but I still need to move it over to CIT Bank which consistently pays the highest interest rate I’ve been able to find (currently 2.4%).

CIT Bank Has the Best Interest Rate I Can Find Anywhere

If you’re looking for a good bank account to hold your emergency fund, or other cash savings, I highly recommend looking into CIT Bank.

By being online only they are able to keep expenses down and offer the best interest rate I can find without sacrificing service.

Savings Builder


As part of our real estate investing side hustle (see below), my wife got her real estate license mainly to save on transaction costs for our own purchases. However, it costs a decent amount of money to maintain her license ($2-3k per year), so she takes on clients here and there. These are almost exclusively friends, family, and referrals. She doesn’t do any marketing to find clients.

My wife stays home with the kids (a much more than full-time job itself), but we’ve been surprised that she’s been able to net around $15-20k per year the last few years only working a few hours here and there. When she has a client, most of the work tends to be evenings and weekends, so I can watch the kids while she shows houses. I would say she spends less than 10 hours a month on this side hustle.

The realtor income is highly erratic. She might have a closing one month and make $5,000, and then not make any money for 3 or 4 months.

Not much to report in May. My wife took on a buyer client that may or may not pan out, and helped a few people find rentals for which she is still waiting to be paid.

Related: Everything I’ve Ever Done to Make Money



Real estate crowdfunding brings in the holy grail of truly passive income. As we get busier with young kids and family life, we are trying to transition some of our gains from active real estate investing into more passive investments. Our real estate crowdfunding income represents the monthly income our invested capital is making for us each month.

If you don’t know what real estate crowdfunding is, you are basically contributing money to a large commercial real estate deal, either as a lender (debt) or as a part-owner (equity). The sponsor of the deal does all the work to find the property, negotiate it, fix it up, rent it out, and eventually sell it. You the passive investor just contribute capital to make the deal happen. You also get absolutely no say in how the property is run, so by far the most important aspect of my due diligence is looking at the sponsor and their past track record.

There are lots of platforms to get into real estate crowdfunding (RealtyShares – no longer accepting new investors, CrowdStreet, EquityMultiple, etc.) You can also find deal sponsors the old-fashioned way through networking with other people. That is how I’ve found most of the sponsors I’ve invested with.

I’m currently invested in a few different deals:

  • A fund that invests in land deals and single family rental houses
  • An apartment complex that happens to be 5 minutes from my house
  • A fund diversified across multifamily, commercial, and industrial properties
  • A fund that invests in Class C apartments in the Midwest
  • A fund that invests in Class B/C apartments in the Southeast
  • A fund that invests in retail shopping centers
  • A life settlement fund (not real estate, but still passive private equity)

Over time, I generally expect my passive real estate investments to return 12-15% per year (IRR). They are all long term investments though, with the money locked up for 5-10 years. Some give me a monthly payment of the cash flow the property generates, and some don’t pay out until everything is sold off in 5 or 10 years.

May Update: Several of the deals we invest in pay out their preferred return quarterly, so January, April, July, and October will have abnormally high cash flow. This month we received $899 from all of the crowdfunding deals we are invested in.

How to Get Started in Real Estate Crowdfunding

If you’re brand new to real estate and don’t have a lot of money to invest, I would recommend starting small. Two platforms I like are Groundfloor and Fundrise.

GROUNDFLOOR Logo NoBackground e1557848673704 - Extra Income Report: How We Made $24,159 in MayGroundfloor – Groundfloor allows you to participate in loans backed by real estate (as little as $10 per loan). I’ve personally gotten an annualized return of 12.5% over the past couple of years across all the various loans I helped to fund.

While that is certainly no guarantee of future results, I do think that real estate is one of the safer ways to invest in debt because you have a hard asset behind the loan (unlike with peer to peer lending where the only thing you have is a credit score and a promise to pay).

Invest in real estate loans with Groundfloor for as little as $10 (and get a FREE $10 sign up bonus!)

fundrise logo make extra moneyFundrise – Fundrise lets you invest in a diversified portfolio of real estate with as little as $500. Because it is a private fund and your money is tied up for 3+ years (unlike a public REIT) the returns tend to be higher, and the low minimum makes it a good introduction to crowdfunding.

Our own personal Fundrise portfolio is highly diversified across equity and debt deals, and in different geographic locations. I like that Fundrise gives you details on all of the individual properties you are invested in through the fund.

Start investing in real estate with only $500 with Fundrise


Rental properties are where our side hustle journey began. We are now 5 years in, and currently have a small portfolio of 7 units. We aim to make about $300 cash flow per month per unit, which has gotten harder to do the last couple years as real estate prices have risen. You can read the story of how we got started in real estate investing here.

All but one of our rentals we self-manage (one rental is in a different state), so we market the property, pick the tenants, and answer the phone when there are problems. Most months nothing happens and there isn’t really anything to do but deposit the rent, but sometimes we get an emergency call that water is pouring out from under the house and we have to figure out how to deal with it. We’ve built up a good list of contractors we trust, which has helped tremendously in keeping costs down and tenants happy.

RELATED: How to Use the 1% Rule to Find Great Rental Properties

One thing I don’t include in the cash flow is the principal paydown on the mortgage. While this isn’t money coming in to pay the bills, it does slowly increase our net worth as the tenants continue to pay down our mortgages. Here’s the breakdown by property.



extra income from rental properties chart

Overall, if everything is running perfectly – we collect all the projected rent checks, and our only expense is the mortgage payment, we would cash flow about $4,000 per month. That is the absolute ceiling, and of course you have to factor in other expenses such as repairs, property management, and vacancy.

You lost over $7,000 this month?!

Yes you read that right, we LOST $7,082 on our rental properties this month.

This is the reality of rental property investing. If anyone tells you that you just buy a single family rental, collect the rent, pay the mortgage, and the rest is a steady flow of cash into your bank account every month, they are lying to you. Over time, our properties have averaged out to give us a good return. But we’ve had good months and bad months – even good years and bad years.

When we closed on our flip property, we decided to use a majority of those profits to do some capital improvements on our duplex. I debated whether to include that in our cash flow numbers here, because it makes them look REALLY bad. Even though these improvements are somewhat optional, I want to be as transparent as possible with all our expenses. We’ve had some really good years with our rental property cash flow, but this year due to these capital expenses, we will probably be overall negative from a cash flow perspective.

If you want to get into rental property investing, make sure you’re in it for the long haul. I’m still confident that these are great assets to own to add to our net worth over time, but sometimes over the short term, things don’t look so great.

Here are the highlights for May:

  1. Our Indiana tenant was evicted. With everything else going on, it was nice to be able to count on the steady cash flow from our Indiana property. But that changed when our tenant stopped paying rent and was evicted. We are wrapping up about $2,000 in turnover costs to get the unit rent ready again (not reflected in the cash flow yet) and it should be back on the market soon.
  2. We’re spending $21k on our duplex. The duplex was our very first rental property. It has an interesting (read: terrible) roof – in the middle is a normal pitched roof with shingles that slopes down to a flat roof on both sides. We’ve had issues with leaks almost every time it rains, and we’re finally spending the money to address it by getting rid of the flat roof. Unfortunately, that will cost us about $17k in total between the 2 sides. But I am looking forward to no longer getting tenant calls about a leaky roof. In addition to that, we’re about to spend another $4k on a french drain to hopefully correct some drainage issues we’ve been trying to band-aid for years.
  3. We renewed 2 leases for another year. The leases are up at the end of June for two of our houses, and both tenants decided to renew for another year. Hooray!

All in all, it looks like 2019 will be a bad year for cash flow. Some days I love owning rental properties. Other days I just want to sell them all and be done with it. Such are the trials and tribulations of a real estate investor.

But cash flow is only a small part of the reason I own rental properties. All of our properties are in good locations with good appreciation potential, not to mention the fact that the tenants are paying down our mortgages, and any income we get is very tax-advantaged. I’m not worried about the long term, and still believe rental properties are one of the best ways to build wealth.

extra income through side hustles

Blogging – $149

I’ve earned a few affiliate commissions from products I’ve recommended (thanks to those of you who signed up using my links – I’d love to know what you think of the products!)

This month, I got a $149 payout for various affiliate commissions. It’s not much, but it’s fun to make a little income from my hobby. It’s worth noting that I’ve earned $435 year to date, which is almost at my annual goal of $500!

For now, I am really enjoying the process of writing out my thoughts on various personal finance subjects, and trying to figure out what kinds of content my audience gets the most value out of.

If you want to see our past income reports, check them out below:

What do you do to make extra income on the side? Let me know in the comments!

Andrew Herrig is a finance expert and money nerd and the founder of Wealthy Nickel, where he writes about personal finance, side hustles, and entrepreneurship. As an avid real estate investor and owner of multiple businesses, he has a passion for helping others build wealth and shares his own family’s journey on his blog.

Andrew holds a Masters of Science in Economics from the University of Texas at Dallas and a Bachelors of Science in Electrical Engineering from Texas A&M University. He has worked as a financial analyst and accountant in many aspects of the financial world.

Andrew’s expert financial advice has been featured on CNBC, Entrepreneur, Fox News, GOBankingRates, MSN, and more.

2 thoughts on “Extra Income Report: How We Made $24,159 in May”

Leave a Comment